It’s been a while since I’ve sat down to really compare paddles in depth, but after spending a lot of time with both the Bread & Butter Loco and the Selkirk Boomstik Summit Edition, I finally felt ready to talk about them. What makes this comparison interesting to me is that these paddles gave me two completely different experiences. One became my comfort paddle, while the other surprised me in ways I honestly didn’t expect.
Back in October, I purchased the tan Bread & Butter Loco and quickly fell in love with how it played. Since then, it’s been my main paddle throughout an entire 3.5+ men’s winter ladder league season and countless rec games. Even after trying other paddles, I kept coming back to the Loco. There’s just something about the balance of control, firmness, stability, and confidence it gives me that works perfectly for my game.
Honestly, there’s a reason I bought another one.
The newer Azul version feels a little different compared to my original tan Loco. The tan version feels firmer and less plush, which is actually why I prefer it right now. The Azul almost reminds me more of my Tornazo or my Vatic VSol Pro V7 LH with its slightly softer and plush response. It still feels loud and solid, but different enough that I noticed it immediately.
I’m continuing to break it in because the sound and feel of my tan Loco are a huge reason why I love that paddle so much. It may just be a one-off variation and honestly doesn’t negatively affect gameplay, but it’s something worth mentioning for players who are really sensitive to paddle feel and response.
Now let’s talk about the Selkirk Boomstik Summit Edition.
Honestly, the colorway helped convince me to finally buy it. But it wasn’t an easy purchase. The Boomstik is expensive, and I actually almost returned it before fully committing to using it. Not because I didn’t like the paddle, but because I was honestly nervous about damaging it. It reminded me of getting a brand new expensive iPhone and immediately wanting the most protective case possible. Except with the Boomstik, I didn’t even want to add edge guard tape or anything extra because the paddle really isn’t designed for that look.
Once I finally brought it indoors for rec games with friends earlier this year, I started understanding why so many competitive players love this paddle. The Boomstik absolutely excels at shaping the ball. The spin, power, and responsiveness immediately stood out, but what impressed me most was how well it handled defensive transition shots and resets off the bounce.
A lot of times in transition, players don’t have time to perfectly shape the ball or apply heavy topspin. Sometimes you’re simply reacting and sticking the paddle out there trying to survive the point and get ready for the next shot. That’s where the Boomstik shocked me. There were so many moments where I simply put the paddle out defensively and the ball somehow found its way safely back over the net.
Compared to the Loco, the Boomstik gives more help in those emergency defensive situations because of its pop, sweet spot, and stability. And we all know trying to slice against heavy slice isn’t always ideal either.
One area where I’ve had more success with the Boomstik is definitely the two-handed backhand drive. This paddle absolutely makes the ball scream off the face. The combination of power, grit, and responsiveness makes aggressive drives feel effortless at times. The InfiniGrit texture also does an amazing job helping shape the ball and generate spin on drives and drops.
I completely understand now why high-level competitive players gravitate toward this paddle. It’s aggressive, explosive, and incredibly dangerous in the right hands.
Even after all of that, I still keep going back to the Loco.
One major reason is how it performs in quick kitchen exchanges and volleys. The Boomstik feels slightly sluggish near the kitchen compared to the Loco. I think the shape and handle length both play a role in that feeling. The Loco just feels quicker and more natural in hand during fast exchanges.
Another thing I noticed is that I hit the upper edge guard area more often with the Boomstik than I do with standard elongated paddles. I can transition almost effortlessly between paddles like the Loco, Inferno, Tornazo, or Vatic VSol Pro V7 because they all share a more traditional elongated square-top shape. The Boomstik’s curved shape creates a different feel and timing window for me, especially during quick reactions. It’s not necessarily bad — it’s just different.
Because of that, if I start a competitive rec session or league night with one paddle, I usually stick with it the entire session. Only toward the very end will I start rotating in other paddles like the Volair Shift, Tornazo, or my favorite backup paddle — the metallic blue Inferno.
In the end, the Loco is still my main paddle. It simply fits my game best. I trust it more with drives, dinks, drops, kitchen exchanges, and overall consistency.
But this comparison honestly gave me a whole new appreciation for the Boomstik. It truly is an amazing paddle. For serious tournament players or competitive league players, I absolutely understand the hype now and would confidently recommend it. For casual rec play, though, I think the Loco is probably the easier paddle for most players to enjoy consistently.
If you decide to pick up a Bread & Butter paddle, feel free to use discount code TECHYETI at checkout. It truly helps support both the blog and the channel. And if you decide to pick up a Boomstik or another Selkirk paddle or pair of shoes, feel free to use my referral link below as well.
Thank you all again for the support. Until next time, enjoy the spring weather and here’s to another full summer of pickleball.


















